I am still struggling with the right time to use restorative practice in class. I have used it a lot in the playground and find that often with the younger children they almost just want to be listened to and have someone hear their grumbles. So getting them to explain to each other how it makes them feel means they feel as though they are being heard. Asking students 'what do we need to do to make this right?' they will often volunteer the suggestion of apologising on their own. I have noticed that even within my class I need to work on developing the language that they use to describe how they were feeling because often they will use angry when really it might be that they are frustrated and maybe their actions came across that they were angry so they need to be able to better explain this, or you get the generic 'I felt sad' answer.
I have used restorative chats in class but find it a difficult juggling act between it being the right time and not taking away from learning times. I have found that there are occassions during guided reading/writing/maths where various children completing independent follow up tasks are being disruptive. It would be an opportune time to have a restorative chat about their behaviour, who it is affecting, how it makes me feel, and how we can make it right. BUT I am often torn. Restorative chats can't really be rushed you need to approach them calmly and not appear like quickly give me the answer I want to hear because I need to get back to my reading group. Therefore it is hard to know if I should interupt a groups learning for 10 minutes when they weren't the ones mucking around. I know that in the long run the children's disruptive behaviour should minimise and it may get to the point one day where all I need to say is I need to catch up with you for a restorative chat shortly and that maybe a reminder to get back on task. Fingers crossed!
It was interesting using circle time on the first day back at school following the course in the holidays. I modelled what I wanted from the students (to talk about how they felt coming back to school) I said I was excited to be coming back, seeing them all again and hearing about what they did in their holidays and that I was well rested after a good holiday and made sure I went to bed early last night. It was interesting hearing them talk about their feelings. One girl came to school late and was upset because we were in the hall not where she had expected us to be in our classroom. When it came to her turn in circle time she said she was excited to be returning to school because she liked school. Others then piped up saying no you were crying when you came into the hall you were sad. But I talked to the class about them being her feelings and that she could share what she wanted and talked about how she now felt happy again because she had found us.
During the two-day course Marg talked about building relationships and how when we get tired we will often revert to the more authorative figure. I guess I am more conscious of this and how I could have approached the situation differently now. There are some students in my class who need constant reminding of how to sit on the mat and manage their behaviour or work independently. When I have reminded these students constantly throughout the day I can sometimes feel myself becoming annoyed by this. I have used some restorative chats with these students but like anything it is an on-going process that hopefully will get easier as the students and I become more confident with the practice.
Hi Danielle
ReplyDeleteI have to agree with you. It is hard to find the time in class to have a poper R chat with chn who are being disruptive. I can see the benefits of having a really good discussion and talking about feelings but when they are continually not listening on the mat it is really hard! Shouldn't they just know by know to sit still and listen!
I guess we keep trying but it is hard to keep cool, clam and collected "all of the time". we can only do our best!
Marcelle
I have recently had some girl problems in class and found myself again in another situation where the accused flatly refused that she had said what she had. The trouble was there was more than one witness to the language used and who it was directed at. This meant it was really difficult to then move forward. So I called in Myra for support. It was great to watch her overcome this hurdle and like me saying she was confused because more than one person was saying she had said it. In the end she took the approach with the girl that maybe it wasn't what you meant to say. We then moved forward on the bases that hypothetically if you had said it how could we make it right? It was interesting that when the affected parties were asked how could this be made right? They all said to put it behind them and move on. I felt myself wanting to jump in and say 'and apologise.' Which was interesting for me to bite my tongue let the children run it in a way that they wanted to and realise that perhaps an apology is the adult response and it may not always be necessary. Near the end when they each had to agree to move on from this and promise not to use that language again the child who had said it struggled to make this promise despite everyone else going first. In the end Myra did threaten the consequence room and this was nice for me to see that we can use the more punitive when the restorative has been exhausted. Exhausted being the operative word as by morning tea that day I felt exhausted! Since then the girls have been meeting with Myra each day for a week or two post the incident. While the initial conferencing took close to an hour the outcome has been worth it and has given those girls the language and strategies to sort some things out themselves.
ReplyDelete